When Your Kid Says ‘I Don’t Know What to Write’
For parents · 6 minute read
You’ve cleared the table, found a pencil that isn’t broken and put a clean sheet of paper in front of them. They look at it for a long moment. Then: “I don’t know what to write.” Sometimes it comes with a slump, sometimes with tears, sometimes with a sudden, urgent need to go to the bathroom.
It’s easy to hear that as “I don’t want to,” and sometimes that’s what it is. But more often, a child who says they have nothing to write is describing honestly how it feels from the inside. Here’s why, and what to do about it.
Why a blank page is so hard
A blank page asks a very big question: what do you want to write about? The answer could be anything at all. For a young kid, “anything” isn’t freedom. It’s fog. Grown-ups know the feeling from being asked “So, tell me about yourself” and suddenly forgetting every interesting thing that has ever happened to them.
On top of that, a young writer is doing several hard jobs at once: coming up with an idea, holding it in their head, turning it into a sentence, remembering how a lowercase g goes, sounding out words, and leaving spaces and periods in the right places. When all of that lands at the same moment, the idea is usually the first thing to fall out.
So the goal isn’t to make your child more creative. They have plenty of ideas; you hear them at dinner every night. The goal is to make the first step smaller.
Start from something real
Made-up stories aren’t the only kind. Kids often find it easier to begin with something that already happened:
- What happened today that was funny, gross or surprising?
- What did your pet do that nobody else saw?
- What’s the best thing you’ve ever found on the ground?
- When did you get hurt, and how did you get better?
- What’s something you know how to do that I don’t?
A true story can turn into a made-up one halfway through. “Our dog ate my sock” is a fine story. So is “Our dog ate my sock and turned into a sock monster.” Let them drift.
Pick from three
Instead of “What do you want to write about?”, offer three specific choices:
Do you want to write about a dragon who can’t breathe fire, a kid who finds a door in the backyard, or a dog who gets lost at the zoo?
Choosing is much easier than inventing. And once they’ve chosen, kids often change it (“Can it be a dragon who breathes bubbles?”), which is a good sign: now it’s theirs. Say yes.
You can do the same thing one step at a time: three choices for who, then three for where, then three for what goes wrong. Write the winners at the top of the page, and the story is half-planned before the first sentence. For a bigger pile of choices, 60 Story Starters for Kids has first lines sorted by theme.
Talk first, then write
Writing is slow; talking is fast. Ask your child to tell you the story out loud before writing any of it. Say “Then what?” a few times. When they’re done, tell it back in a sentence or two: “So the dragon sneezed bubbles all over the castle, and the king loved it?” Now they know what their story is, and writing it down is remembering instead of inventing.
If the writing itself is the sticking point, you can write while they talk, and they can copy one sentence of it or add the last line. The story still counts. Making up a story and putting letters on paper are two different skills, and kids can practice each one without the other holding it back.
The one-sentence story
Tell them they only have to write one sentence. Just one. Somebody did something:
- A dog ate a pizza.
- The robot fell in the pool.
- Grandma rode a horse to the store.
A one-sentence story has a who and a what happened, and that’s enough. Plenty of kids, having written one, will add a second (“And then he burped”). If they don’t, the page has a sentence on it instead of nothing, and you can stop there for today. A finished small thing beats an abandoned big one.
Draw it first
Some kids think in pictures. Hand them the paper and say, “Draw your story first.” While they draw, ask about it: “Who’s that? What’s he holding? Why is the sky green?” By the time the picture is done, they’ve told you most of a story. The writing becomes a caption, one or two sentences underneath.
This works especially well for kids who still form letters slowly. The drawing lets them get the whole idea out at their own speed, and the picture holds the idea in place while they write.
Let them be silly
Kids sometimes stall because they think a story has to be good, or true, or serious: the kind of thing that gets pinned on the classroom wall. Lower the bar on purpose. Ask for the silliest story they can think of. A cow in a tutu. A burp so loud it knocks over a building. A teacher who turns into a pancake at lunchtime.
Silly isn’t wasted writing time. A silly story still has a who, a where and something that happens, and it’s much more fun to finish. Kids who are giggling tend to keep going.
Small things that make it harder
A few well-meant habits can make a stuck kid more stuck:
- Fixing spelling in the middle. Let them spell words the way they sound, or draw a line for a word and keep going. Fix it afterward, if at all.
- Hovering. Sit nearby, but do something else for a minute. Some kids freeze when they’re watched.
- ”Just write anything.” It sounds helpful, but “anything” is the whole problem.
- Taking over. If you start supplying the ideas, the next blank page gets harder, because they’ve learned that the ideas come from you.
- Pushing past tired. After a long day, a very short story, or none, is fine. Try again tomorrow.
When it’s homework
When a teacher has assigned a topic (“Write about your weekend”), the same moves still work. Talk it through first. Pick from three moments in the weekend. Draw the best one. Start with one sentence. The assignment picks the topic; it doesn’t have to pick the first sentence too.
Seeing it move
For some kids, the push to write comes from wanting to see something happen. In Stick Figure Storytime, every sentence a child types plays out on a little stage, so even a one-sentence story gets a reward right away. These are good ones to start with:
Whatever you try, the moment to celebrate isn’t when the story is good. It’s when there’s something on the page that wasn’t there before. For what to do once the words start coming, see How to Help Your Child Write Their First Story.
Try it with a story
Stick Figure Storytime turns the sentences kids type, or say, into a little play: hand-drawn stick figures act out each one. It’s free in your browser and on iPhone, iPad and Android, with no accounts and no chat.